Offer #2. There's one elite player in either deal, and he would be coming to you. I'm of course talking about Greg Jennings, who you can put in the line-up regardless of the match-up, where as everyone else are flex plays/bye week fillers.
QB: Cutler, Freeman RB: Blount RB: Bradshaw WR: A. Johnson (Gaffney) WR: Wayne RB/WR/TE: Nicks (Boss) RB/WR/TE: Tomlinson (Greene, Jennings, Davis) K: Brown DST: Giants
Thanks for the opinions! seems like everyone is pretty one sides that deal #2 was better... but Bowe looked pretty great this past week as well.. he actually had a BETTER game than Jennings... and Jennings, minus that huge 82 yard td pass had just an avg game... also anyone think maybe its better to just stay put? having a good back up qb could be important in fantasy playoffs..
i would do the 2nd trade but its close....i slightly prefer jennings over roy....all the other players involved are garbage IMO, including palmer. yes u should have a viable backup qb, but try to get someone who is better than palmer. Im not a fan of jennings, but he has the most potential out of anyone in these trades..go ahead and do this trade
If you're going to do either, do the 2nd. Bowe had a great week... this week. That's it. He and Cassel just don't have a proven connection yet. Jennings also has the bonus (as much of a bonus as it is for someone to be injured) that Finley is injured meaning he should see more targets. Overall, you're really only affecting your flex so it won't make a huge difference, and Palmer isn't a hugely needed backup (you could find similar value on the WW unless you're in a really deep league). If you want to make a trade, do the 2nd. If you don't care too much, you're fine where you are.