keep moreno or hillis WHIR

[MWRtodayy]

aaron rodgers
desean jackson, calvin johnson, michael crabtree, johnny knox
knowshown moreno, jahvid best, peyton hillis, felix jones, ryan torain
celek

as you can see, im weak at rb but always trying to upgrade my team. Someone who needs a rb way way more than me wants calvin johnson and peyton hillis or moreno for his andre johnson. Now i love megatron but i'd prefer to have andre. The question is would u give hillis or moreno? moreno is finally coming back from an injury and did pretty okay against a good d. His schedule is easy most of the way.

Hillis has been excellent putting up big numbers but this is a CLE rb who many teams didn't look at as a true rb so how long can he keep putting it up?

[taw856]

Between the two, I'd rather move Hillis as I expect Moreno to be more productive when he plays (admitting that his health is always an issue).

But that said, especially if you think you're weak at RB, I wouldn't get weaker at RB for a small upgrade at WR. Megatron is a legit WR1 and Andre isn't going to outperform him by a significant enough amount to be worth it. Stand pat.

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=481621

[geeksincleats]

This trade isnt attractive enough for you to make it a 2fer1. I agree that your RB's arent crazy good to begin with, so it certainly isnt a good idea to make it at all weaker.

Try to consolidate the mediocrity somehow, like a 2fer1 knoxx & hillis for a surefire WR2 or RB2. Look for a Cedric Bensin, Mike Turner, MJD, (last two are stretches in this example) or a Deangelo WIlliams type RB; talent but unlucky lately. This will help more as its never good to have medium guys in the lineup and a bunch of slightly less than medium guys on the bench. I'd rather have studs on the field and a sharp drop off on the bench, after say my primary backup.