Big Trade with CJ2k and Rodgers - Need Help?

[rrshepard]

Need some help in making a decision.

I give Rodgers, Bradshaw, Gafney, Henne
I get Kolb, Vick, Chris Johnson, Welker

My team.

Rodgers, Orton, Henne
Bradshaw, Benson, F. Jackson, Barber
Fitzgerald, Maclin, Gafney, Armendola
Finley, H. Miller,
Birones
Jets D

Is this is a good deal or not. I could also have Malcomb Floyde instead of Welker if anybody likes him better. WHIR..thx

[Cardphan]

Anytime you can get the #1 pick, take it. Especially since you have Orton, who is a higher rated QB than Rodgers. You may want to upgrade at the WR position though instead of aquiring so many QB's that you won't need.

[rrshepard]

The only reason I am offering Hene also is to get both Kolb and Vick since nobody knows who will be the starter and it would be nice to have them both for that reason. Anybody else have an opinion.

Thx

[grooner10]

I really like this trade for u.
At qb if Vick comes back and plays like he was it's almost an upgrade, if he doesn't well you only lose a little from Rodgers to kolb
At rb u upgrade
At Wr u upgrade

[kronik85]

do it, you're getting good upgrades at multiple positions. but if he's getting rogers, i doubt he really cares if he gets henne.

[dblj9911]

I would say I would do this trade, CJ is a huge upgrade for you. I think that Rodgers is a elite qb, but with the injuries that they have suffered it may limit his effectiveness and between the Philly duo and Orton you will be fine at qb. I would say yes to this now. Good luck.

viewtopic.php?t=481513

[jimhorn888]

yes do this trade immediately.
Here's mine:
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=481512