Calvin/Bradshaw for CJ2K? WHIR

[phorts]

10 Team League - Standard Scoring - Non PPR - 1 Keeper

Start: QB, 2RB, 2WR, RB/WR, TE, K, D

Offer

I Give: Bradshaw, Calvin Johnson, 2011 3rd Rd Pick

I get: Chris Johnson


My Team:

QB: Rodgers
RB: Gore, Bradshaw, Forte, Hillis, Mathews
WR: C. Johnson, Floyd, Bowe, Bryant
TE: H Miller

My WR are pretty shallow as it is and my RB corps is pretty deep, so, even though it IS Chris Johnson, i'm not sure this is the smartest deal for me. I LOVE Megatron...but he is on a BYE week and he can be inconsistent (like most WR). Bradshaw has been solid so far but Jacobs IS still there. Of course the 3rd rd pick makes it difficult..but i'm sure i could get then down to a 4 or even a 5.

Does this help my team?

(I traded Foster for Calvin/Forte in preseason...doh)...maybe this can help me redeem myself.

Leave a Link. I always help in Return..thank you!

[phate83]

don't do it, like you said your RB's are stout, and you'd gain minimal points and lose one of the top 3 receivers in the game in the process and another draft pick.

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=481526&p=3264832#p3264832

[619ers]

10 Team League - Standard Scoring - Non PPR - 1 Keeper

Start: QB, 2RB, 2WR, RB/WR, TE, K, D

Offer

I Give: Bradshaw, Calvin Johnson, 2011 3rd Rd Pick

I get: Chris Johnson


My Team:

QB: Rodgers
RB: Gore, Bradshaw, Forte, Hillis, Mathews
WR: C. Johnson, Floyd, Bowe, Bryant
TE: H Miller

My WR are pretty shallow as it is and my RB corps is pretty deep, so, even though it IS Chris Johnson, i'm not sure this is the smartest deal for me. I LOVE Megatron...but he is on a BYE week and he can be inconsistent (like most WR). Bradshaw has been solid so far but Jacobs IS still there. Of course the 3rd rd pick makes it difficult..but i'm sure i could get then down to a 4 or even a 5.

Does this help my team?

(I traded Foster for Calvin/Forte in preseason...doh)...maybe this can help me redeem myself.

Leave a Link. I always help in Return..thank you!

Id say dont do the trade. CJ2K is definitely a keeper, but if youre tryin to win the league, stick with what you have. Megatron is beasting this year and Bradshaw is quietly putting up big numbers. CJ2K will do what he does but I think youd be losing pts weekly in this trade. If youre willing to, Id say trade away Mathews, Forte, Bowe, Floyd, or Bryant by themself or in a package deal for an upgrade at WR. Hope this helps!

When you can...

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=481574