Either one should have more production than Murphy. I think both are pretty similar, and both should be used mostly for match ups, so it doesn't matter too much which you pick. Go with whomevers schedule you like more.
I'm not sure you should use a #3, it depends on the way your league behaves. In my league I would with your team on Garcon first, then Branch. I'd go for both. That's because my league makes alot of waiver claims and its easy to move up the list in a week or 2. I like Garcon's upside more, but he will be an every other game producer in that offense. I like him slightly more than Collie so that says something... but who am I HELP ME viewtopic.php?t=481586
12 Team 4 player keeper no strings. Standard roster/scoring except can start TE at flex QB Stafford, Kaepernick RB Foster, McFadden, SJax, Moreno, B. Tate WR D. Thomas, Nicks, D. Moore, Maclin, A. Brown TE M. Bennett K Jani D Lions, Dolphins
Thanks for helping with mine, I would definitely go with Garcon. Manning is the better QB and as you saw last week likes to target Garcon. he has had so many targets since returning from his injury. Good luck!