QB CONTROVERSY TRADE....NEED HELP...WHIR

[nst3409]

So I have Tom Brady and Kyle Orton and got an offer to give up Orton for Randy Moss.

I'm not sure if I like the trade or not but I need a WR. Also, its a keeper league and I got Orton pretty late, probably around the 13th pick or so (rule is if we keep someone, we lose the pick in the round before he was drafted next year). I was thinking about keeping Orton just for insurance but idk if his great year is just a big blip in his career.

What do you guys thnk? Should i try and get more value for Orton or would you offer up Brady just because he is a big name and might sucker the kid in?

[dg12x]

If you need the WR, I'd definitely do the deal with Orton, especially as Brady already has his bye week and Orton has not.

[rde0921]

I agree that you should make the moss trade especially if you need the WR. I think orton's production is at its highest value right now. Looks like tebow might be taking some more snaps also.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=481721

[FatFoot]

I don't know. This isn't an easy one. Orton is a top QB right now, and if he has 2 more good weeks, his value post bye is WAY higher than Randy Moss.

Right now it's fair. Fair-ish.

If Orton has 2 more excellent FF games, I think it's more like Orton for someone in the Wayne/White/Megatron etc tier. And before anyone says that Randy Moss is right there with them... age/work ethic + super sketchy Favre health and the threat of Tavaris Jackson... no, he aint.

viewtopic.php?t=481709

[Foolio]

If you're hurting at WR I'd do the trade.. Brady is gonna be just fine with Branch there now..

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=481705