Big Trade - PLEASE HELP - WHIR 100%

[jeter2411]

I give up: MJD, Andre Johnson and Hines Ward
I get: J Charles, Roddy White and Reggie Wayne

I see Charles as a slight downgrade from MJD with the potential to be better if he gets more carries as the season goes on. White is about even with AJ (maybe a slight downgrade) and Wayne is a nice upgrade to Ward.

Thoughts? Please leave your link.

[ajaymehra]

Lets see

Charles is sharing carries with Jones ... although he will be the starter as the season progresses (Haley is keeping him fresh for a playoff run)
White is a beast this season
Wayne isnt getting his ... I have Wayne on my team. He's a stud...but he has Garcon, Collie, and Clark getting more looks.

Ward should be getting more looks now that Bens back ... need to be patient with him
Andre the giant is ... well ... Andre the giant
MJD ... could go either way

I think Andre owns both White and Wayne
So finally - I wouldn't do that trade ... no way I give up Andre and MJD together

please help with mine - viewtopic.php?t=481732

[jwalk1786]

I wouldnt do it. You cant keep andre quiet all yr and Shaub is startin to play better the more people start takin the run seriously...
Hines Ward had a MONSTER game compared to his first 4 or 5...you gotta stick with him. hes prob. not as good as White but Wayne (even tho i think hell still be a top 10 wr) is splitting touches with SOOOO many people i think hell be a big then small pt wr kinda guy...
stick with what ya got its a pretty good thing..
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=481736