Should i propose this trade? WHIR

[rde0921]

I am in a 10 team ESPN standard Non PPR league. We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 RB/WR, 1 TE, 1 DEF

My Team......

QB: Orton, Schaub
RB: S. Jackson, D. Williams, Torrain, Tolbert, F. Jackson
WR: M. Austin, Colston, Crabtree, Garcon, Knox
TE: Watson, Pettigrew
DEF: San Francisco

His Team......

QB: Vick, Farve, Cassell
RB: Rice, Mendenhall, Addai, Barber
WR: R Moss, Boldin, R. Williams, Gaffney
TE: Gates, T Gonzalez
DEF: Bears

I was thinking about proposing this trade...

I give: Torain, Crabtree and Pettigrew (or colston instead of crabtree)
I get: Addai and T. Gonzalez

What do you think? Is it fair to both sides? Leave a link i WHIR.

[Foolio]

I don't like that trade for you, mainly because I don't like Addai at all.. And, Watson is producing nicely, you don't need Gonzo..

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=481705

[nst3409]

I dont' like the trade either to be honest. Addai is so untrustworthy and gonzalez hasn't done much except for one big game, i have gonzalez in a couple leages and im nott too thrilled