Trade Welker for Kolb? WHIR

[ajaymehra]

Should I trade Welker for Kolb?

My Team

QB: Palmer, Vick
RB: Gore, Jamaal Charles, Peyton Hillis, Marshawn Lynch
WR: Reggie Wayne, Andre Johnson, Wes Welker, Deion Branch, Patrick Crayton, Mike Williams
TE: Brent Celek

12 person league ... slim pickings
I can drop Palmer and pick up Bradford for this week ... and possibly Stafford for next week
Im hoping Vick comes back, but if not I need a good QB

WHIR

[jwalk1786]

I wouldnt, atleast not until you find out whos for sure gonna be the starter in philly

[geeksincleats]

Get Kolb now! While there is uncertainty in the air as Vick recovers. Come 2 weeks after the bye Kolb will be starting if he has a good game this weekend. Its the safe play, handcuff Vick now.

[jwalk1786]

the trade will still be there after this weekend, thats how good welker is. The guy is tryin to get you to trade hoping vick starts...becasue honestly, everyone says KOLB should, but reid said vick will....do you think u should trade welker for a backup or even better, a handcuff?...thought so...wait til they know for sure.

[geeksincleats]

He'd be obliterated at QB if the trade isn't there. Why risk all that for a WR3 on his team.

Unless the guy holding Kolb has Romo/Rivers or better, the trade partner may end up using his new found Eagles starting QB instead of trading.

Welker is a good WR but only great in PPR formats. I'd rather give up my WR3 so I could atleast have a fantasy football season with hope, rather than taking a 50/50 guess at whos going to be the starter in PHI.

If you're in it for Vick, you gotta be willing to own Kolb.

[ajaymehra]

geeksincleats....thats what I was thinking too
Im just wondering if Kolb is the answer here
Welker hasnt done jack since the 1st week
I have Deion Branch too .... so I was thinking use the big name while its worth it and get Kolb

thanks guys