Big Trade Need Help!!! WHIR!

[njp5118]

I was offered a trade where I send Mendenhall, Hillis, and Driver and receive MJD, Nicks, and B. Jacobs. This is a tough call since MJD has potential, but has so far been out-produced by Mendenhall. I also love starting a third RB in my flex as opposed to a WR, which is why I'm having a tough time moving Hillis here.

Rest of Team in 12 Team Standard Non PPR:
QB: Brady
RB: Mendenhall, Benson, Hillis, Green-Ellis, F. Jackson
WR: Steve Smith, Driver, Ochocinco, Owens, Garcon

Any help is much appreciated I'm having a real hard time deciding here. Leave a link.

[njp5118]

bump. please?

[phorts]

Absolutely not. You dont have the RB Depth to handle that trade as Jacobs is no more than a potential TD Vulture (and 50/50 at that as they put Bradshaw in on Goal line situations sometimes). MJD is solid, of course, but this is by no means a by low offer. He's also got a horrendous matchup away vs KC this week and Jax QB situation is horrendous.

Preseason you'd be creamin in your jeans for this deal...not now though. Mendenhall is gunna explode now that BB is back (and was before then), Hillis is a human wrecking ball and while Driver is definitely no Nicks, the upgrade there isnt worth your time. (Nicks has been covered by wet blankets this past couple weeks and will continue to be and S Smith will be lovin the limelight again).

Besides, do you want to be that heavily invested in NYG's offense and Jax mess? Not me. You dont need to do this deal, and you shouldnt.

Good luck and please help w/ mine:

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=481869&p=3266486#p3266486

[c0megets0me]

I would NOT make this trade, MJD is on a team that will be playing from behind more times than not.

[njp5118]

i got him to take out Hillis. It's now Mendenhall, Ochocinco, and Green-Ellis for MJD Nicks and Mike Williams, which I am leaning towards doing.

[phorts]

Its your funeral. Hope you like watching the Giants.

[MWRtodayy]

i'd definately stay put


viewtopic.php?t=481898