I think you gottan go with Witten here. Cooleys not a bad option but Witten is gonna get more looks. Trade away Cooley. With Dalas Clark out for the seasone someones gonna be lookin for a solid TE
I appreciate the feedback, but Cooley is out performing both Shianco and Witten by at least 20 points so far this season. Witten doesn't catch TD's while Cooley is McNabb's number 1 receiver
If I were to trade anyone it would defiantely not be Cooley
Witten's been down a little so far, but I think he's still one of the stud TEs, so you roll with him. The only thing that might give me a little pause is if the Giants pass rush is as dominant as it's been, he may need to stay in and block more. And Cooley's not a bad play. But on balance, I still think you start your best player.