Mendenhall for (Moss or Harvin)..............

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

8 team league with fairly deep rosters.

6pt = TD (rushing, receiving, returning)
1pt = for every 20 yds rushing or receiving
2pt = for +150yd rushing or receiving in a game


Mendenhall's owner sent an unofficial trade offer for:

i give: MOSS or HARVIN
i get: R.MENDENHALL

should i pull the trigger? if so for which one? HARVIN? ---- even though he's been the more targeted and better producer the last 3 weeks?


QB: Brees
RB: A.Foster
RB: A.Bradshaw
WR: R.MOSS
WR: R.Wayne
W/R: G.Jennings
TE: D.Keller
DEF: BEARS
K: Bironas

BN: C.Palmer
BN: J.Addai
BN: Pierre Thomas
BN: Ronnie Brown
BN: Thomas Jones
BN: PERCY HARVIN
BN: Steve Smith (CAR)
BN: C.Cooley

[woowoo crew]

i would give moss for mendenhall. harvin has added value b/c of the returns, plus he's been on fire lately. i think it's a very nice trade for you.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=482481

[utility-hook]

I would give Moss and keep Harvin. Harvin is more involved in the game. He gets his hands on the ball more than Moss. He rushes, receives, & he is their return guy.


Mine
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=482483&p=3269474#p3269474

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

I would definitely rather have harvin these days, surprising to say. Moss for mendy is great for you

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

If I could get AP instead of Mendenhall, would that be any better?

[taw856]

I'm in agreement with prior posters that I'd rather trade Moss than Harvin since at this point Harvin looks to be the more productive player.

As to your second question, yes, I'd rather have AP than Mendenhall, though either is a nice deal for you.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=482461

[utility-hook]

Yes, Peterson would be better. Now that Roethlisberger is back, I think Mendenhall will start losing more carries. The Vikings know how big of a weapon Peterson is & will still try and get Peterson the ball at least 20 times if they can.

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

Mendenhall for Moss was vetoed by our League Manager.

[tmacuf]

Why was that vetoed? Moss is touted as being a total beast this year for some reason so it makes no sense...
HELP ME
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=483026&p=3271699#p3271699