Potential Trade - Help, WHIR!!

[redbirded]

I am thinking of proposing this trade:
I give up:
M. Ryan
Charles and or Jones
R. Moss
FOR
Moreno
Desean Jackson


Here is my Roster and league detailsLeague #1 (COMMISH, 7 seasons!) Roster - 10 team keeper (3rd season), non-ppr, ret. ydge points, 1 IDP,
OB - A. Rodgers
QB - Matt Ryan
QB - Roethlisberger
RB - R. Rice
RB - A. Foster
RB - J. Charles
RB - T. Jones
RB - Green-Ellis
WR - Calvin Johnson
WR - Randy Moss
WR/TE - Dustin Keller
WR - J. Knox
WR - Dez Bryant
DST -NYG
DST - Best on Wire
IDP - Leon lahndry
K - Prater - Den.


and his:
QB Tony Romo*, Dal QB O [Breaking News and Video] 9 117
RB Adrian Peterson, Min RB [Breaking News] 2 111.5
RB LeSean McCoy, Phi RB P [Breaking News] 6 99
WR Santana Moss, Was WR [Breaking News and Video] 20 61.5
WR Brandon Lloyd, Den WR [Breaking News] 4 85
WR/TE Hakeem Nicks, NYG WR P [Breaking News and Video] 2 98
DP Justin Tuck, NYG DE P [Breaking News] 1 35.5
D/ST Bears D/ST, Chi D/ST 1 38
K Matt Bryant, Atl K [Breaking News] 3 59
Bench DeSean Jackson, Phi WR Q [Breaking News and Video] 12 71
Bench Knowshon Moreno, Den RB [Breaking News] 25 51
Bench Arrelious Benn, TB WR [Breaking News] 126 6.5
Bench Donovan McNabb, Was QB [Breaking News and Video] 13 103.5
Bench Visanthe Shiancoe, Min TE [Breaking News] 23 26
Bench Darren McFadden, Oak RB [Breaking News and Video] 4 106
Bench Ronnie Brown, Mia RB [Breaking News] 35 39

Thought I would try to get someone out of Big Ben or M. Ryan as having 3 QBs is pointless and kind of a waste of a roster spot. With Romo going down for him I though I would feel him out. He is willing to deal for Ryan but won't give up too much, and with 3 solid QB's I can't ask for much.
What does everyone think???

[Kegglers]

I think you'd be giving too much. I'd try to do Ryan for DJax straight up. Or offer him Ryan/Jonesz for Jdax/Moreno.



Got a sec?
viewtopic.php?t=482569

[Sex Panther]

I am thinking of proposing this trade:
I give up:
M. Ryan
Charles and or Jones
R. Moss
FOR
Moreno
Desean Jackson


Here is my Roster and league detailsLeague #1 (COMMISH, 7 seasons!) Roster - 10 team keeper (3rd season), non-ppr, ret. ydge points, 1 IDP,
OB - A. Rodgers
QB - Matt Ryan
QB - Roethlisberger
RB - R. Rice
RB - A. Foster
RB - J. Charles
RB - T. Jones
RB - Green-Ellis
WR - Calvin Johnson
WR - Randy Moss
WR/TE - Dustin Keller
WR - J. Knox
WR - Dez Bryant
DST -NYG
DST - Best on Wire
IDP - Leon lahndry
K - Prater - Den.


and his:
QB Tony Romo*, Dal QB O [Breaking News and Video] 9 117
RB Adrian Peterson, Min RB [Breaking News] 2 111.5
RB LeSean McCoy, Phi RB P [Breaking News] 6 99
WR Santana Moss, Was WR [Breaking News and Video] 20 61.5
WR Brandon Lloyd, Den WR [Breaking News] 4 85
WR/TE Hakeem Nicks, NYG WR P [Breaking News and Video] 2 98
DP Justin Tuck, NYG DE P [Breaking News] 1 35.5
D/ST Bears D/ST, Chi D/ST 1 38
K Matt Bryant, Atl K [Breaking News] 3 59
Bench DeSean Jackson, Phi WR Q [Breaking News and Video] 12 71
Bench Knowshon Moreno, Den RB [Breaking News] 25 51
Bench Arrelious Benn, TB WR [Breaking News] 126 6.5
Bench Donovan McNabb, Was QB [Breaking News and Video] 13 103.5
Bench Visanthe Shiancoe, Min TE [Breaking News] 23 26
Bench Darren McFadden, Oak RB [Breaking News and Video] 4 106
Bench Ronnie Brown, Mia RB [Breaking News] 35 39

Thought I would try to get someone out of Big Ben or M. Ryan as having 3 QBs is pointless and kind of a waste of a roster spot. With Romo going down for him I though I would feel him out. He is willing to deal for Ryan but won't give up too much, and with 3 solid QB's I can't ask for much.
What does everyone think???

I'd do it, Ryan is a quality QB who's young, but Big Ben & Rodgers are better options.

Moss is old & it looks like in decline.

Charles/Jones is hefty - but the timeshare thing sucks.

IMO you're getting younger at WR (which is nice in a keeper) w/out losing any production really.

Moreno may not be flashy, but iit's his gig & he's young.

[blatini609]

you make out really well for a keeper league. I would definitely try and trade jones before charles, but either way i'd do it.

viewtopic.php?t=482589

[redbirded]

It should be noted that we can only keep players drafted in the 4th Rd. or later and DJAX was a 2nd rd. pick so keeping him is not an option.
I'm just wondering if he'll go for it???
How do you guys see it from his point of view?

[blatini609]

he'll probably see it as a wash all the way through except that he gets a good QB out of it. He won't be starting moreno over mccoy, allday, or mcfadden, and djax while better than moss isn't the biggest drop off, and his WR situation is a lot better than the QB situation.

[redbirded]

just shot it to him with T. Jones in there instead of Charles for now. Thinking he's not going to go for it. Will update soon. Thanks for the help!

[redbirded]

Looks like he's going for it. Anyone heard any new news on DJAX?

[redbirded]

He opted for Big Ben instead - -
So ,
Roth,
R. Moss
T. Jones

FOR
DJAX
Moreno

How did I make out???