Andre for Big Ben/Megatron?

[Harry Halfzeees]

What are everyones thoughts on this trade. I am the one giving up Andre. I feel it would be a huge upgrade with my QB situation.


Cutler, Favre
A. Foster, Addai, Torain, Felix, K. Moreno
Andre Johnson,Welker, Santonio holmes, Gaffney, P. Crayton
Heath Miller
Vinateari
Giants D NO PPR, 10-TEAM

[djtw]

Yes do it. Big Ben will be a good upgrade for you and megatron and Andre should almost equal out.

[Rrolack]

I would do this as well.

[danielpneal]

While I don't agree that CJ and AJ will equal out (AJ will be better), I would still do it. The drop off isn't that dramatic at WR, and the QB upgrade is well worth it.

Help please with mine: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=482688

Thanks.

[nimzox]

Go for it! You need help at QB and the drop off between Andre and Calvin wont hurt you that much. (I think Calvin will catch more TDs than Andre this year) Help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=482660

[Harry Halfzeees]

I was also thinking that Stafford really only throws to one reciever as well...haha

[Ozymandias19]

Do this, I agree as someone said prior to me, AJ and CJ will not be equal, CJ will out perform AJ this year for sure. You get a better WR and a better QB for one WR. I see no negatives here.

[Harry Halfzeees]

Whats your reasoning for thinking CJ will be more productive than AJ?

[Ozymandias19]

Less weapons than the Texans, meaning more targets. He is three inches taller, there is no one that is going to out jump him at 6 foot 5. They both run a 4.3, I believe he gets more targets. And lastly, the Lions are always behind, their defense is worse than the Texans.

[Harry Halfzeees]

I believe this is a go even more now