Lost Romo...need trade advice and pronto

[legance]

I am in a 12 team, H2H points league (non-keeper). You can start 1 QB, 2 RB's, one Flex (RB/WR), 1 TE, 1 Kicker and a D/ST

My current roser:

QB: None (Romo gone)
RB: Hillis, Gore, Thomas Jones, CJ Spiller
WR: Wayne, Coston, Britt, Williams (Sea), Louis Murphy
TE: Miller, V. Davis
D/ST: KC
Kicker: Gould

The trade I have been proposed is one of two:

1. Ben Rothlesberger and Jahvid Best for Frank Gore or
2. Mick Vick and Best for Frank Gore

I think I might be able to plug my QB issues with a tandem of waiver QB's but the QB's in the trade are tempting, especially Big Ben (Vick is an off game or a scramble gone bad away from loosing his starts). So....would you make either of the proposed trades? I was also thinking of asking for McFadden in place of Best.

[sweettortilla]

I agree, these are very tempting. But I'd probably take my chances on the waiver wire. Gore is the deal-breaker for me here. Love him too much. He's been solid and SF is going to need to rely on him even more with the Alex Smith injury.

I could make a case for taking either of those two trades you've been offered, but for now I'm feeling "stand pat".

Good luck!

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=482775

[legance]

thank you for the response....

Yeah, I am leaning towards no but I would be a little more interested if I can get McFadden in place of Best and then a toss up between Big Ben and Vick (Although I would lean towards Ben....maybe not the great upside of Vick but less downside and a slightly better playoff schedule).

Still fell that it may leave me thin with reliable running backs. By the way, I am currently 6-1 so I could still focus on a QB tandem off the waiver wire.

I did respond to your post by the way.

[prophecy135]

I dont like either of those trades, Gore is too valuable, and QB's can be had off the WW to fill in, IE Stafford, Bradford, Fitzpatrick, Young.. Pick up a pair and play the better matchup. If I were giving up Gore, I'd expect a QB on par with like a Brees.

Adding DMC makes it a little more interesting, but he's so injury prone. I'd still say no.