was shown Roddy and Bensen for Rice and AJ...

[joeyemma]

10 team redraft....no ppr 6 for all td's....1 for 20 passing...1 for 10 rush/rec

we start 1 qb 2 rb 2 wr 1 flex k d

Brees/Big Ben

Rice/Turner/Fred Jackson/Caddy Blount

AJohnson/Welker/Wallace/Branch/Heath Miller/D Alexander

I was shown Bensen and Roddy for Rice and AJ.....I tried to sub another wr for AJ....no go. I said no.


Did I do the right thing?

[bellringer21]

10 team redraft....no ppr 6 for all td's....1 for 20 passing...1 for 10 rush/rec

we start 1 qb 2 rb 2 wr 1 flex k d

Brees/Big Ben

Rice/Turner/Fred Jackson/Caddy Blount

AJohnson/Welker/Wallace/Branch/Heath Miller/D Alexander

I was shown Bensen and Roddy for Rice and AJ.....I tried to sub another wr for AJ....no go. I said no.


Did I do the right thing?

I think so....White has been the #1 WR this year and I dont see any reason to believe that will change (AJ and Wayne are 2 & 3, NIcks #4 with Romo out). Even though Rice split carries last week with McGhee, I like Rice better than Benson. I'm actually trying to trade Benson for Rice by adding others. The difference between White and AJ is slim, while the difference between Benson and Rice is a bit more (not by much though). The Rice/AJ side is the best.

Any thoughts for me?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=482841
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=482842

[Luca Brasi]

Hmmm...that trade is pretty balanced. AJ, when healthy, is only slightly better than Roddy. But AJ gets hurt a lot. Benson and Rice have historically performed similar, BUT Benson gets 20+ carries a game, this is crucial.

I say stand pat if you like your team, but if you make the trade you should not be disappointed.