Interested on your feedback on this trade-WHIR 100%

[unkleskott]

Teams are below. I am thinking of offerring Welker/Britt/Bradford for his Nicks/Vick.

Any feedback here...am I dumb. Is he dumb for taking it? Both Vicks and Nick are on a bye this week, so I think I might be able to use that as part of my sales pitch, also that Vick is ...fragile, which he very well might be...anyways, just wanted to get thoughts from the pros before I offerred it up.

Thanks!

8 man PPR league.
Starting lineup:
2QB, 2RB, 3WR, 2FLX ,1TE, 1K, 1 D/ST

My team is:
QB: Schuab, Bradford, Roethlisberger
RB: Gore, Foster, Turner, Torain, Mathews, Snelling
WR: CalJohnson, Welker, Britt, Harvin, Wallace, AGonzo, Bryant
TE: Moeaki

His team:
QB: Favre, Orton, AlexSmith, Vick
RB: CHarles, Best, McCoy, Stewart, Barber
WR: Austin, Nicks, AJ, Ocho, Crabtree, RoyWIlliams
TE: Heath Miller, Celek

[Luca Brasi]

(I don't see Vick listed on his roster there. Typo?)

Looks like the offer is slightly in your favor but I doubt he'd take it. His QB depth sucks and he will need Vick. He may counter for Big Ben. If so, try to get AJ off his hands instead of Nicks.

Help please: http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=482848

[unkleskott]

Sorry, Vick is now posted on there.

Do you think it is too risky to have Schuab, Foster, and AJ on my team???

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

To be honest I don't see the point in trading for Vick. With Schaub and Roethlisberger you have a very solid QB staff and there is no point to add to it. If I were you I would try to upgrade at TE before most places.

[brianj29]

the trade is ok i would try to get orton in deal if u have to go position for position if not its ok but his qbs suck so good luck

[jp05ser]

i would def do the trade if he goes for it...Vick prob wont play since u have big ben....i agree with above that maybe u want to sell high on big ben and throw him in. I love the addition of nicks to your team though....he has replaced steve smith as the #1 option in NY and has a chance to take EVERY catch to the house def try to get it done!

help with mine please??? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=482835

[unkleskott]

Alright guys, I will give it a shot....thanks!

[tmacuf]

I don't see why he'd go for it, welker and bradford are not worth much, Britt is risky compared to Nicks... Do it if you can, you don't need those guys
HELP ME
viewtopic.php?t=482881

[prophecy135]

To be honest I don't see the point in trading for Vick. With Schaub and Roethlisberger you have a very solid QB staff and there is no point to add to it. If I were you I would try to upgrade at TE before most places.

This.. there is no need for this trade. And even if you put it out there I doubt the other owner would go for it. He has a very solid WR core and he will need Vick as his WR core is weak, and Bradford wont fix that.