Trade Offer Advice re: R. White/A. Foster 100%WHIR

[jmkratt]

Ok, its getting to be crunch time and I am looking to make a move.

12-team H2H, 6pts all TDs, 0.1 pt/yard rush/rec

This is a keeper league with a rather quarky system. You can keep 1 player from your top 3 picks and another from picks 4 through FA in the previous year. Your two keepers from the previous year are counted as your 1st and 2nd pick. The 2nd tier keeper is extremely valuable. As all TDs are 6 pts, QB's are also very valuable.

My roster:

QB - Peyton Manning
RB - C. Benson, B. Wells, R. Williams, B. Jacobs, T. Hightower, J. Snelling
WR - R. White, S. Smith (NY), J. Gaffney, S. Johnson
TE - O. Daniels, B. Watson

His roster:

QB - A. Rodgers, R. Fitzpatrick
RB - A. Foster, J. Charles, R. Mathews, M. Barber, M. Tolbert
WR - W. Welker, H. Ward, B. Lloyd, J. Knox, K. Walter
TE - Z. Miller

As it stands now I can keep 1 of the following: P. Manning, C. Benson, R. White as the 1st keeper. My 2nd keeper would be...Wells?

The trade offer:

I give: R. White and C. Benson
I get: A. Foster and J. Knox

I would get an immediate boost at RB but take a hit at WR.

However for next year I would be able to roll with P. Manning and A. Foster.

What do you guys think? Any opinions, comments, advice would be appreciated.

I will respond to everyone who leaves a link!

[isobro]

Sounds like a cool league. Tough one, but I would try to get someone else besides Knox. See if he would upgrade to either Ward or Welker. It is just so hard to trust bears receivers, even with Cutler at the helm. Their new offense isn't as spectacular as people assumed it would be with Mike Martz (sp?). I personally am not solf on foster, but he is certainly performing like a top back, then youw ould get him next year.

help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=482969

[DemonDeacon]

Id ask if he'd throw in Lloyd (prob wont) first, just b/c you can. If not I still think you should make this trade. Your team should have a solid chance at making a Super Bowl push this year and next year you will have arguably 2 of the top 10 picks in your league as a foundation

help?
viewtopic.php?t=483020

[tmacuf]

Yeah go for Lloyd benson is much more valuable than Know and I dont see Arian higher than the 5th best back when all is done this year.
HELP ME
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=483026&p=3271699#p3271699