Please Help Comish Wont approve this trade!!!!!

[Marky Mark]

First of this is a trade between My friend in Tenn while Im in Kc and my friend is 1-6 and im 3-4 he says this trade is cheating and that we wont let this trade go through... Im am going to post this link in the league so everyone can see the responses good or bad so any comments are helpful thank you for your input! PS What did I tell all of you About Dexter McCluster and Sir Mike Williams from SEA please check out my other post!

OK now on to the Trade:

Im giving up
Matt Forte
Vick
Devon Bess

What Im getting
Jackson
Orton Woodhead



I think this a perfectly fair trade... Please Any comments or input is great THANKS and good luck in your seasons

[sweettortilla]

I agree! Perfectly fine trade.

I really dislike the whole commish veto thing. I think people get carried away with it, and this is an example of that. This is not a blatant case of collusion, and that's what a commish should be worried about. (See http://www.chinstrapninjas.com/veto-pow ... eague-ffb/ for more info).

Forte vs. Jackson - Forte has had more value, but Jackson as #1 RB in Green Bay should always have value. Unless this is a PPR league, I don't see this as outrageous.

Vick vs. Orton - Vick has big point appeal, but is a big risk guy too. I like Orton's ability to throw and get you big games. I think that's totally fair.

Bess for Woodhead - not sure why these guys are even in the deal, but these are two "who cares" guys. They might score a TD here and there and get some points, but otherwise middle of the road dudes.

Hope that rationale helps.

Help with mine ? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=483057&p=3271870

[bubbershrimp]

Which Jackson are we talking about, Desean or Brandon?

[Marky Mark]

sorry wrong jackson guys steven jackson from stl

[vengy101]

Agree with the above...this is a fair trade. No trade is going to be an exact point for point trade if that's what he is looking for. There is nothing wrong here.

I went through the same garbage with my commish that had a trade of mine vetoed and then proceeded to trade Forte for MJD straight up last week. Unless it is obvious collusion it should be approved.