FJones & ERoyal for JCharles?? (Dynasty)

[ThePrez]

Would you trade Felix Jones and Eddie Royal for Jamaal Charles??

This is the 3rd year of a dynasty league (keep everyone) and we do get 0.5 pts per catch.

My roster is pretty stacked so I think I have the flexibility to trade Jones/Royal.

Standard Yahoo roster plus RB/WR flex.

My roster --

QB's -
Philip Rivers (SD - QB)
Kyle Orton (Den - QB)
Eli Manning (NYG - QB)

WR's -
Andre Johnson (Hou - WR)
Marques Colston (NO - WR)
Greg Jennings (GB - WR)
Mike Williams (TB - WR)
Jeremy Maclin (Phi - WR)
Eddie Royal (Den - WR)
Brandon Tate (NE - WR)
Blair White (Ind - WR)

RB's -
Chris Johnson (Ten - RB)
Adrian Peterson (Min - RB)
Rashard Mendenhall (Pit - RB)
Felix Jones (Dal - RB)
Brandon Jackson (GB - RB)
Mike Tolbert (SD - RB)

TE -
Jason Witten (Dal - TE)

K -
Mason Crosby (GB - K)

DEF -
New York (NYJ - DEF)

Thanks!!!

[passthekiesch]

Wow, you are absolutely loaded at RB. That's not even funny.

I would do the trade. Charles is going to be good for years to come and especially considering Thomas Jones' age, you would think the potential for Charles as a feature back in the future is really high. Plus I don't see Royal or Felix Jones being all that valuable down the road in a Dynasty format. Maybe Jones, but Charles >>>>> Jones.

viewtopic.php?t=482909

[phorts]

Wow, Nice team. First, i dont think you need to do anything, but i like this deal for you.

I spent days debating a trade in my dynasty that had me sending Charles for Felix and Bernard Scott. I did it because i felt that both players were equal long term, and Scott gave me a much needed handcuff to one of my RB1s (Benson). I didnt like the deal for the immediate future (1st half of season), but i felt that in the end I would made out.

For you however, the tables are turned. I'm leaving Royal out of this on purpose, as i dont think he's a loss to you at all with that WR Corps and shouldnt be a factor in this decision. What makes this a done deal for you is the fact that it's a PPR. EVEN IF Thomas Jones continues to be the main between the tackles guy, Charles will still be the main reception, and in a PPR, CHarles has slightly more value than Jones. Dallas is a mess, Romo is gone, the offense can't get ANYTHING going and Barber is still there to get his useless work in. Barber will probably be gone next year, which makes Jones a nice long term option, but Choice will just step into that role and it will be a virtual wash (IMO obviously).

I truly feel that Charles has more big play ability in him. Just the eyeball test tells me that this guy can take it to the house in any given moment. Felix Jones CAN, but to date hasnt really been that guy for any sort of consistency. Charles is getting his points this year even WITH TJ there, and McCluster... and he's never really been an injury risk.

Jones has been.


The safe bet is Charles....do it up.

Good luck and please help w/ mine: viewtopic.php?t=483072

[ThePrez]

Wow, you are absolutely loaded at RB. That's not even funny.

I would do the trade. Charles is going to be good for years to come and especially considering Thomas Jones' age, you would think the potential for Charles as a feature back in the future is really high. Plus I don't see Royal or Felix Jones being all that valuable down the road in a Dynasty format. Maybe Jones, but Charles >>>>> Jones.

Thanks for the reply!

Yeah it was a great year to start a dynasty league. A lot of solid rookie RBs.

I went early on Mendenhall in the 5th rd, but got CJohnson in 7th rd, Felix in 8th... and actually took a long shot on JCharles in the 18th rd.... but he wasn't sniffing the field and at the time I had to make a FA move. Can't make all the right moves! lol

[Joeybagadonuts]

Yes. J Charles has nice dynasty value.

Help in return: viewtopic.php?t=483017

[bungle613]

I see it is both Felix and Charles as talented but unknown commodities. Giving up Royal is fairly meaningless and if you believe Charles to be int eh better situation or more talented then cut the deal. It is a coin flip for me as to who will have more value in 2 years.