Trade Bradshaw and Austin for Charles, Harvin, and Bryant

[jarobert]

10 Team Non PPR. Bradshaw with a bye this week.

I get Charles, Harvin, and Bryant for my Bradshaw and Miles Austin.

I posted this earlier and got a unanimous no go but I thought I'd see if anyone feels differently.

Full disclosure.. I want to make the deal to help me this week but I think it can be a winner long term.

How much of a drop off is there from Austin to Harvin?

[WaCougMBS]

I don't know if the dropoff is that big at all, to be honest. Add in that I like Charles a bit more than Bradshaw and you get the upside of Bryant (who Kitna really seemed to look for - granted it was just over one half of one game, but still) - considering that the deal seems pretty even, or maybe a bit in your favor, AND it helps you this week, I'd actually say pull the trigger...

Before Romo's injury and the Moss-to-Minny trade, I would said 'nay', but with those two happenings, I say 'yay'

[BSbludolf]

I say do this in a heartbeat if it werent for Favre injury. Purge Austin as soon as you can, as he wont do anything with Kitna at the helm regardless of this trade possibility. Bradshaw is legit which makes it hard. Kitna will throw to Bryant a lot however because of familiarity and raw talent. Charles is just waiting to break out. F it. Take the trade