Gore/Garcon for MJD/Austin? WHIR

[Spiegepj]

I was just proposed the following trade. I am wondering if I should try and counter with another WR (Williams, Knox, Amendola) or should I accept the trade with Garcon? This is a 12 team, PPR League and I am currently 4-4.

Give:
Frank Gore
Pierre Garcon

Get:
MJD
Miles Austin

My Roster:
Ryan, Matt ATL QB
Fitzpatrick, Ryan BUF QB

Gore, Frank SFO RB
Turner, Michael ATL RB

Amendola, Danny STL WR
Garcon, Pierre IND WR
Wayne, Reggie IND WR
Williams, Roy DAL WR

Celek, Brent PHI TE
Winslow, Kellen TBB TE

Bironas, Rob TEN PK
Nugent, Mike CIN PK

Bears, Chicago CHI Def
Titans, Tennessee TEN def

[toobitter]

i don't really like this deal, because it's questionable how much it actually helps you.

Gore for MJD on paper sounds good, but MJD isn't the same guy anymore. he won't be as reliable as gore in the long run.

and as soon as romo went down, austin's value dropped. he's still a solid play as he showed last week, but with kitna throwing him the ball, you can't count on him like before. and garcon is healthy in a pass first offense. i don't think austin's much of an improvement over him.


lil' help
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=483956

[Spiegepj]

Anyone else have any feedback? The deadline is today

[nvj362]

I prefer Gore/Garcon

[Remy]

I would do the trade if it was MJD and Williams (TB) They have a great playoff schedule. If not I would stay put.

My Topic
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=484109

[dawg17]

I prefer MJD and Austin - I would go ahead

Please help me
viewtopic.php?t=484111

[bubbershrimp]

I would much rather have Gore/Garcon. Gore has been the most consistent RB all season and MJD has shown very little. As far as the receiver end, there might be a little upgrade for Austin over Garcon but not as much as expected with the loss of Romo.

[sgramando]

There is no added value here, I would stay put. Gore is a more productive RB and Austin is going to lose value with the addition of Kitna who has better timing with Williams and likes to check down to his TE's.

[Therobsclub]

No way! Ride Gore and Turner into the playoffs. Dallas is a mess and austin has a case of the drops this year not to mention KITNA is his qb. Stay put!

help?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=484127