A weird trade offer, but pls help quick, should I? WHIR

[unkleskott]

He offerred me HIS White/Stafford/Flacco in echange for my Harvin/Schuab/Turner. Obviously he needs a decent RB, and I would love to snag White. I don't really have any use for 4 QBs, but....should I just do this???

8 man PPR league.
Starting lineup:
2QB, 2RB, 3WR, 2FLX ,1TE, 1K, 1 D/ST

My team is:
QB: Schuab, Roethlisberger, Fitzpatrick
RB: Gore, Mathews, Foster, Turner, Torain, Snelling
WR: CalJohnson, Welker, Bryant, Harvin, Wallace, AGonzo, Britt
TE: Tamme

His team:
QB: Stafford, Flacco, Rogers
RB: Lynch, MacFadden, Caddy, PThomas
WR: White, Maclin, Breaston, Driver, JacobyJones
TE: ZachMiller, Gonzo, Shianco

[unkleskott]

Should I counter White and Flacco for Turner and Schuab?

[Whosyomamma]

I'd go Turner, Fitzpatrick (push the fact that he's scored more pts/game than many top5 qb's last 4 weeks) for Flacco and White. Don't do the original trade!

Thanks for the help on mine...

[unkleskott]

You make a good point, and that is why I'm almost starting to think that I would rather have Fitzpatrick than Schuab....is that dumb? I am almost for sure think I am starting Fitz over Schuab this week at the very least...

[unkleskott]

okay, I think I am going to counter offer

MY Schuab/Turner

for

HIS Rodgers/White

his RB situation in an 8 man league is weak, and he needs another strong back...

thoughts?

[homer233]

good idea about fitzpatrick, i would totally counter with him instead of schaub.

roddy white is a freaking stud, if you try to simplify the trade, maybe just do turner for roddy white, there i said it.

i fricking love roddy white the best receiver in fantasy this year, and will stay there. ad you have good depth to do it.

thanks for your help i a, accepting the austin trade

[unkleskott]

Okay, the guy doesn't seem to be budging off his original trade offer...although I have no need for 4QBs, should I take this deal...I have tried throwing out Rodgers/White for Schuab/Turner....heck even Flacco/White/MIN for Fitz/Turner, but he isn't biting. His original trade offer is still on the board of

Flacco/White/Stafford for Schuab/Harvin/Turner.

Dumb to accept?

[KTang58]

I don't think it's necessarily dumb to accept but I don't get why he's trying to give you two QB's and not budging. White would really help strengthen your WRs but Turner looks good down the stretch too. You'd be getting two really nice QBs. Maybe, if you take this trade, you could use a QB (or two) in another trade?

[dblj9911]

You are really deep at rb and could use one of them to get yourself some help at wr. I do like White, but I think that I would rather have Turner on my roster. I would look to move Gore and keep Turner and Foster as your main rb's. Are there any other teams that need rb help and deeper at wr?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=484516