His McFadden for my Wayne....WHIR!!!

[Therobsclub]

QB: Brees, Vick
RB: Mendenhall, Moreno, F Jackson, Jacobs, Spiller, R. Bush
WR: A Johnson, R Wayne, B Marshall, L Evans, M Williams(Sea) - Breaston is on waivers right now.
TE: Witten
K: Carpenter
D: Saints

Do I make this deal?

Start 2 Rb's and 3WR's....NON PPR

Things I like: McFadden leads the league in yards per game....also is scoring TD's....also is involved in the passing game, easy playoff schedule

Things I don't like: He has Bush behind him, has a bye next week, is he durable? Has played against mediocre teams.

Also...when I use the yahoo evaluator it says I lose 18 points and he gains about 20+. Don't know if I can trust that.

I should also not that the guy I am trading with is in first place and him getting wayne would help him a lot. Because his WR's would be Austin, Jennings, Wayne. His RB's are CJ and Foster which is why McFadden is expendable to him.

What should I do? I've been 50/50 on this because I believe Moreno and Bush will do good enough for me with my team. Basically I'm just missing a good rb. I think I'd lost bigger if I got rid of wayne. What do I do?

[bryanjmcc]

I say go for it bro, you're good on WR'r and him with RB's. I heard a Robert Gallery interview and they are for real, the line will hold, he will stay healthy, and he won't fumble anymore. Do it, do it..

I was in a similar spot. My Forte for His B. Marshall. When lloyd comes off Bye next week I'll be stacked in my WR heavy league, and I still have Rice/LT/Moreno..

[MWRtodayy]

both sides win, but his team is looking BEAST with that trade. I dont see how he'd lose unless the players get injured or have an off week. But you do get a top RB(only when hes healthy so pray he doesnt get injured again). As long as he's healthy, bush is a non factor. Reggie wayne is one of the top wr's but peyton just has too many mouths to feed and has confidence in all his receivers.

viewtopic.php?t=484268

[Kegglers]

I'd pull the trigger on it. Peyton spreads the ball around too much to consider Wayne a solid WR1 anymore. McFadden has been everything you could ask for this year. The Raiders are for real. Enjoy the ride.



Help here?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=484289

[SirGrotius]

I'd do this trade, too. It's a good one for either side, and I've always been a McFadden fan. McFadden is the better athlete at this point in his career than Wayne, but Wayne is on the better team. Go with the athlete.