Trade: Andre Johnson for Calvin Johnson - Opinions? WHIR

[grouchomarxist]

12 Team, Semi-PPR
1pt per 10 yds, 1pt per 3 recepts, 6pt TD, 2pt 100yd recv bonus
1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 1DST

Andre for Calvin?

It would appear Megatron has more value. Calvin's owner is in a must win situation this week and says he likes AJ's matchup better.
Am I missing something?

Factor's I've been considering:

Pros
Calvin's playoff matchups are better.
He's preformed better so far.
AJs nagging ankles injury could get worse.


Cons
Texans will likely be fighting for a playoff spot in the last weeks.
Lions likely won't have much to play for. Always a chance Megatron sees less play for risk of injury.
Trust the rookie Stafford vs Shaub?
Andre typically gets more recpts and yardage which is slightly more valuable in our semi ppr league.


I've been told by some that this is a wash and by others its a no-brainer.
Any thoughts would be appreciated.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Q Eli, Vick, Garrard
RB Foster, McCoy, Moreno, Greene, Blount
WR Fitzgerald, Manningham, Burleson, Crabtree, A Johnson
TE Hernandez
K Vinatieri
DST Bears, Chiefs

[JimiRayThunderaxe]

I would do this in a heartbeat for all the reasons you mentioned in pros.

Plus, something appears to be out of synch with the Texans passing game. It seems like they just can't get into a groove.

If Sean Hill can't bring down Calvin Johnson then how can you doubt him?

AND I really do think AJ's injury is going to hinder him to the point where he may need to sit out a game.

Go for it.

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=484320