Better keeper for next season: Blount or Spiller

[Brianst]

I am 3-5 with the possibility of the playoffs slipping away, not completely giving up hope yet but am trying to trade Gates for a QB and Spiller problem is he wants Blount.

If I lose this week he is gone for any good keeper.

[dblj9911]

I think that overall Spiller has more talent and will be the better player, but one problem is Buffalo's offensive line. There O-line is pretty bad and having a hard time getting a ground game going, but if you are in a ppr league he should be better and better each week. I think that Blount will be a productive player, to me he is a Rudi Johnson type, will get a little over a 1000 yards each year and anywhere from 7-10 tds. I think that Spiller will match that easily each year and have much more opportunity to exceed that. What are your keeper rules?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=484516

[Brianst]

I think that overall Spiller has more talent and will be the better player, but one problem is Buffalo's offensive line. There O-line is pretty bad and having a hard time getting a ground game going, but if you are in a ppr league he should be better and better each week. I think that Blount will be a productive player, to me he is a Rudi Johnson type, will get a little over a 1000 yards each year and anywhere from 7-10 tds. I think that Spiller will match that easily each year and have much more opportunity to exceed that. What are your keeper rules?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=484516

We can keep 3 players but they cost us the round below where they were drafted the year before. I checked and he drafted Spiller in round 4. He would be worth a 3rd but Blount would only cost me a 17th round selection since he went undrafted.

I declined the trade.

[latsprewell20002000]

Well Spiller is the better choice but with only giving up a seventeenth round pick for Blount i would go that way.