Should I? WHIR

[sjmay]

Thinking about trading Manning, in a deal for McFadden,

Now keep in mind, I am thinking about the future as well, after this season we keep 1 QB, I have Flacco and Manning now,

Here is a deal I am proposing,

P. Manning
L. Fitzgerald
M. Lynch

for

M. Ryan
D. McFadden
M. Colston

Out of these, McFadden would be the only one I keep for next year, as I would keep Flacco over Ryan, now, that might change in the off-season, and I would keep Bowe over Colston, and I would keep McFadden over BJGE and J. Charles.

This still gives me 2 QB to play, then I would be running the rest of the year with

Flacco
Ryan
Charles
McFadden
Bowe
Colston or S. Johnson, or B. Lloyd

rather than

Flacco
Manning
Charles
BJGE
Bowe
Fitzgerald.

Thoughts?
Provide a link for WHIR

Thanks

[sweettortilla]

I'm not sure I can help you objectively because I think Peyton is the man. I think he's the best QB in the biz and if I could hold onto him until next year, I'd do that. I like his chances this year, even with the injuries of his WRs. The Colts will be fighting for their playoff lives, which means good things for his owners until the very end of the year.

Take my man-crush for what it's worth

Good luck!

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=484629&p=3279327