Evaluate this BIG trade please...

[mikeydread9]

PPR LEAGUE!!!

Wayne / Gresham / DWilliams

for

Austin / VDavis / Blount


Who wins and why? This may get accepted or vetoed with your help. Thanks!

[Fuqyu]

For starters, don't veto that trade if you have the option, it's not an unfair trade by any means. As for who wins, it depends on the roster of each team. 1 team is giving up an elite TE, mediocre back, and less productive than expected receiver, while the other is giving up an elite WR, mediocre TE, and less productive than expected back.

[mikeydread9]

It's not my trade. I still think I'll veto it because the better team gets Wayne to go with Andre Johnson. He doesn't care about losing VDavis because he has Tamme. The other team is weak and now loses Wayne but replaces with a weaker Austin and a banged up VDavis? Sorry man, I gotta diss the upgrade to Wayne. Anyone disagree?

[Mana Karma]

i disagree. you can't veto a trade because you dont think its fair... thats up to the team owners/managers to decide.

the only way you can veto is if you have evidence of collusion or conspiracy... and this trade does not seem to have any. SORRY, no veto allowed in my view.

[blatini609]

wah wah wah im veto'ing this because someone's goi ng to have AJ and wayne

[Mana Karma]

since when is there a fantasy football rule that prohibits someone from having to top WRs?

sounds like you made your mind up before you came here... dont ask if you dont want an answer

[blatini609]

and serious reply the guy whos getting miles austin is winning this trade, especially if he's on a losing team. gresham and deangelo are just throw-ins. he's getting three startable people and vernon davis aside from last week when he was out a half has put up double digits in PPR the lsat 4 or 5 weeks. he returned to practice yesterday and is going to be good to go this sunday. Blount is clearly the starting RB in TB and is a way better play than deangelo williams (who's still injured), and let's not forget austin had 117 yds on 7 or 8 catches against jax... DAL collectively got blown out in GB. now that wade's out, who knows what will happen there.

[blatini609]

since when is there a fantasy football rule that prohibits someone from having to top WRs?

sounds like you made your mind up before you came here... dont ask if you dont want an answer

he didnt post that i was being sarcastic and making fun of him.

[Mana Karma]

yeah, i just caught on. good on you.

i can't stand people making judgments about trades.

for example... my league commish tried to veto Tamme for Gates... but you factor in a bye week and the injury, and the trade seems perfectly legit to me.

NO MORE VETOS

[mikeydread9]

C'mon. You know it's Wayne for Austin/Davis. I don't think it's a fair deal. Wayne is a super stud! Austin plays for the 1-7 Kitnas and Davis' QB stinks! He's stealing Wayne for two crappy team players. It's a PPR league and he gets Peyton's #1 target. Who's with me???