Evaluate my Vick trade.

[Dren_man]

10 team, Romo owner. I traded Benson and Garrard for Vick and Choice. I needed a QB pretty bad. My RB's will be AP and BJGE or Tolbert?

[Perfectibilist]

You needed a QB so you traded one-for-one QBs and basically gave away a RB? I don't really like this trade for you at all...

[sheethappens]

Good trade. You moved your 4th best RB for a top end QB to replace Romo. Basically you moved a bench player for you for a starting QB, good job. Normally I don't like giving away legit RB#2 guys but you HAD to move something to get a solid QB once Romo went down and you had the depth at RB to do it.

[cmurda]

I agree that it was a decent, not great, trade. Benson has been disappointing but you can mix and match with BJGE and Tolbert, and you upgraded significantly at QB. Choice is a lottery ticket, but there could be value there.

viewtopic.php?t=484746