Dynasty - 18 Team: Schaub for Stafford/J. Stewart

[haloswin2002]

My team:
QB: (Vick), Schaub, Leinart
WR: (A. Johnson, C. Johnson, Colston, M. Williams -TB), Schilens
RB: (McCoy, P. Thomas, D. Brown), Sproles, Jennings, Scott, James Davis
TE: (Hernandez), Gresham, Olsen
K: (Scobee), Hanson
DEF: (Balt), NE

I have been looking to move one of my 2 QB's to upgrade my RB position. I have been offered J. Stewart and Stafford for Schaub. What do you guys think?

Here is his roster:
QB: (Favre), Stafford, Whitehurst
WR: (Ward, Ochocinco, Smith - Car, Armstrong), Collie, Stuckey, Naanee, Devin Thomas, Ford
RB: (Greene, Foster, Snelling), Stewart, Darby
TE: (Tamme), Graham
K: (Folk)
DEF: (Phil)

On a related note, there is another guy in the league with a loaded team who likes Vick... here is his roster if you can think of any offers I should pursue before this Schaub trade...

QB: (Manning), Young, Rosenfels
WR: (Austin, Dez, Crabtree, Demaryius Thomas), McCluster, Sanders, Robiski
RB: (AP, Best, Turner), Knowshon, Willie Parker
TE: (Keller), Marcedes Lewis, Hoomanawanui
K: (Graham), Gostkowski
DEF: (Cin), Sea

[Phillay88]

Tough decision. I was at the game where Stafford got hurt and it look like he barely even landed on it. I wouldent want to base my Dynasty on a guy that injury prone.
>Bottom Line: Stick with Schaub and be happy.

Another option. I like the idea of trying to trade Vick and McCoy for Young and AP. I think its just a matter of time before Vick falls back to earth and gets injured.

Good luck! Help me with my decision if you have a minute.
viewtopic.php?t=485566

[haloswin2002]

Any other opinions out there? Is the combination of Stafford/Vick too risky... it was just last year that Schaub was injury prone too...

Is everyone off the Stewart bandwagon now? I cant find updated dynasty rankings, so all opinions are welcome.

[haloswin2002]

I hate to make a decision off one opinion,but I think I am going to accept the trade.