Bowe, Marshall, M. Williams (TB) Pick 2 (WHIR)

[Tony Micelli]

10 man, H2H, PPR league, with bonus points for long receptions and long TD's

Who would you rather play and why?

As of right now, I'm starting Bowe and Mike Williams ... thoughts?

WHIR, Post Links.

[markiteight]

You cant bench Bowe after his last couple of performances, ditto williams.

Marshall has been extremely disappointing, only 2 good games this year. If I asked you if you would play WR ''x" - plays on a team with an ineffective running game, who gets double teamed every play, has only 1 TD on the season, hasnt scored a TD since week 3, since then has had 34,30,64,57,127,50 yards you wouldnt start him unless you were desparate - and if you have bowe and williams on your roster that makess you not desparate. Dan Henning clearly hasnt figured out how to get Marshall involved in the offense and he is basically playing the role of a very highly paid decoy. Plus there is uncertainty of how he will go with new QB tyler thigpen so I would leave him on the bench this week, and at least monitor how the QB change is working out. Of course, it is a universal law of fantasy football that the one week you bench him he will have a monster game...
and i'm a bitter marshall owner myself, I have lost my last 2 matchups by 4 and 3 points while my other WRs have been productive on the bench and Im facing a similar dilemna this week, except my other WRs are Mike williams (SEA) and mario manningham and Im tossing up which 2 to start this week...(got vincent jackson coming back next week so that will help)

[BriGuy]

I think I would go with Bowe and Williams.

Marshall has been disappointing this year and I don't like the QB situation in Miami with Thigpen.

[kingmike74]

Thanks for the help man


First off, you cannot bench Williams.

I like Garçon for the second spot if he is healthy. I think the Pats will try, and succeed at keeping Wayne in check and I think Garçon goes big this weekend.

I would not even consider starting Marshall until he strings together a few good ones.

Good luck!

[AsianChexMix]

Bowe and Williams. I know what you are saying about AJ vs Blount (essentially what you are saying) so yeah, I wonder how I'd feel with Schaub still playing. Thanks for the help!

[jonesy37]

I would have to sit marshall from these guys...bowe is going crazy and williams has it going on with freeman.

see mine

viewtopic.php?t=485693

[Wakbrder87]

thanks for the help with mine. i made the mistake of sitting cassel and bowe in one of my leagues in a PPR. I agree with everyone on here going with bowe and williams. But im going to sound like a retard, but i think marshall is going to have a good game with Thigpen throwing. I played him in my league a couple times 2 years back. He had solid outings and won me games. If I was to play him id would sit Williams for Marshall