Do I sit AP for McFadden?? WHIR

[nhgent]

I'm the #1 seed going into the semifinals of a PPR league and have a tough decision on my hands...

Do I sit AP this week against Chicago since I have McFadden going against Denver (Both playing at home)???

My gut is telling me to stick with AP and not overreact to the 36 point effort last week, but I'd like some outside advice!!

Leave a link and I'll help you.

THANKS

[chrisjay84]

You can only start one? Who's your other back because these are two great options. In a situation like this, you have to play your studs and who brought you here. I'd go with AP, just because he's AP and can rack up 150/3 tds anyweek. But seriously, you can't start both?

Please help with mine.

viewtopic.php?t=488219

[nhgent]

I'd obviously start em both if I could....but with no Flex spot, neither of these guys is taking Arian Foster's spot in my line up!!

[chrisjay84]

Ah well I can see why. Good luck though! You should be good either way.

[Mrpu]

Flip a coin...don't think either one of them is going to hurt you. Nice set of RB's by the way.

[britdevine]

Id go with mcfadden, hes on fire, and AP didnt have a very good game vs CHI first time out, and the Vikes looked horrible vs. the Giants

[richp1003]

Yes...Id say McFadden is the play here...the matchup is there..hes been putting up big points...sit AP
Good Luck

[sabomnim]

never thought id say this but go with mcfadden over AD
tough choice tho

[gtiracer06]

McFadden is a beast. If you've watched him closely. You'll see that he runs a little like AP. On top of that, he's the recepient of a lot of dump offs and screens. Tough to sit AP, but he's got the tough matchup and the drama at qb to deal with.

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=488247&p=3295747#p3295747

[LSUby50]

i would never sit AP. My personal philosophy is to not overthink the lineup in the playoffs. AP is an every week starter. the exception would be if he's banged up still

mine?
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=488268