E. Manning, Orton or McNabb?

[toy4x4]

Eli Manning vs the Eagles 11th against the Rush ; 17th against the Pass

or

Orton vs Oakland 26th against the Rush ; 7th against the Pass

or

McNabb at Dallas 17th against the Rush ; 27th against the pass (listed as probable)



I am leaning toward NcNabb. he is more consistent and has a better matchup against Dallas' pass D.

Orton is on a team in flux and has sucked for 2 weeks in a row. Eli, not much better there with the WRs he has.

[med23]

I am liking McNabb here too. He knows the opponent well and although the Cowboys are streaky, I think that the Redskins have a good shot at keeping a balanced and consistent attack this week. Orton is playing a hot team who's weakness is defending the run, not the pass. Manning is pick happy right now, and his WR's might have a hard time getting open consistently against the Eagles especially if the Eagles stop the ground game and get ahead early.

I would go...
1. McNabb
2. Manning
3. Orton

Here is mine
viewtopic.php?t=488229