Eli vs Orton AND Cutler vs Garrard **WHIR**

[krazyjoe8]

I am in the playoffs for 2 seperate leagues and I have a QB dilemma in both.

#1
a.) Eli Manning vs. Philly (S. Smith out, Manningham prolly out and Asante Samuel should be back)
or
b.) Kyle Orton @ Oakland (Oakland has a better Pass D than Philly but Orton is coming off of a garbage week)

and #2
a.) Jay Cutler @ Min (Playing outdoors against a solid Pass Def)
or
b.) David Garrard @ Indy (Indy has a slightly worse Pass Def than Minn and Garrards been a little hotter than Cutler lately)

Thanks a lot for your help, leave your links and I will reply ASAP! ! !

[krazyjoe8]

My instincts say:

1 = A, Trust Eli since Denver has been super sloppy
2 = B, Go Garrard with his better matchup

[charltonsect]

I agree - Eli and Garrard.

help? viewtopic.php?f=19&t=488341

[Questi4110]

Eli and Garrard.

Help me: viewtopic.php?t=488250

[AnddWon]

Orton & Cutler

Orton will bounceback and Cutler will pick apart a very sad Vikings squad in an inter-divisional game.



Your thoughts? viewtopic.php?t=488344

[numLoCK]

Orton and Garrard for me.
Don't think Eli will do much at all this week, Orton will bounce back.
And Garrard is an easy choice imo.

Help? http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=488336

[Dirty Dlamps]

First Team:
Eli is your obvious choice. Depleted Phi secondary and this one may turn into a crap shoot. Orton got shut down last week at Arizona (#25 Pass DEF). Need I say anymore.

Team 2:
I would go with Garrad even though Minns pass Def is rated lower than Indy (12 v. 8 respectively). The only reason Indys pass def is rated relatively high is because everyone runs the ball down their throat. Jacksonville has a bad pass def (#28) and an overall bad Def for that matter so Indy is going to score on them so I wouldn't be to afraid of them going to MJD all day, they will have to throw at some point.

And you really can't trust Cutler, my boy, outside at Minn (outside) especially since it doesn't look like Minn will score much with their QB situation. I think Chi is going to shut down Minn and run the ball all day and make conservative passes.

Help on mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=488346

[LSUby50]

eli for sure, cutler unless there's a blizzard. thanks for your help on mine.