It sucks. I have a very similar situation with AP and i dont know what to do either. I dont think i would start Hightower over AP ever though, stick with AP in that one and pray You can only start one of the those guys in the first match-up ?
Play your stud player even with a poor match up. This is the unwritten rule... unless you had a viable #2 with a good match up. I dont see any of your options as viable #2's with good match ups. Just my opinion. Good luck no matter what you choose!
You have to play ADP, the only other way I would even consider is BJGE> In the playoffs, you want to go with consistency and AP and BJGE are your only choices. Go with the guy you took in the first round in your draft. Thanks for helping with mine!
QB Romo & Cutler; RB: R Grant, R Mathews, F Jones, F Jackson. M Tolbert. & C Williams; WR/TE used as same: G Jennings, A Gates, M Austin, S Holmes, D Keller; Kicker: M Crosby. TD League-bonus-100 yds rushing, receiving, & 300 yard passing.
I hope your gut feel is right about AP especially since I'm playing against him this week. LOL.
Roll with your studs . . . AP. I would consider the Law Firm stud quality this year and the Pats are unstoppable right now. Not the same story in Minnesota with all kinds of problems going on. But like a previous poster said . . . you will never forget losing a playoff game with AP on the bench.