by BearsFan65 » Fri Dec 24, 2010 12:04 am
You have one factor in your equation that I don't have in mine - Matt Schaub. I'm debating Tebow v Eli, and I keep coming back to Eli's ceiling vs. Tebow's floor. But in your case, there's no way I start a rookie in his second start against the worst D in the league over a veteran productive passer against the third or fourth worst D in the league. Schaub is your start, and it's not close. The only possible hindrance to that is if the Texans decide they want Foster to win the rushing title. If they do, 25-30 carries is likely, and that should put them far enough ahead that Schaub won't be passing all that much.
As for Tebow or Eli....I'm still thinking it over. Good luck!