Thrifty's Special

[Kareighuis]

Thrifty recently proposed some rule changes-

Not sure if this was ever suggsted, but I'd like a vote on whether to count the following as points for offensive players

fumble recovery TD
punt return TD
kick return TD

If you want all of the rule proposals, or none of them, please indicate such. If you'd prefer one/some but not others, or would prefer their introduction to be delayed in some way, please indicate such.

Edit- Killing the timer, for all those who haven't had a chance to vote yet.

[thriftyrocker]

Voted all. Doesn't affect player value really. The startable RB/WRs (Harvin, DeSean) only got 1 TD max. Ford and Hester got 3. Both those guys - and any other guy who is both returns and RB/WR - probably gets less returns the more snaps he gets on offense. It's more about not having the mood swing of seeing your guy scored a TD and then figure out it doesn't count in the league you have him.

[LS2throwed]

It's more about not having the mood swing of seeing your guy scored a TD and then figure out it doesn't count in the league you have him.

Ha. Couldn't have said it better, that stings. Your right it doesn't happen much, but I always liked to see it go to that player since he did it.

[Kareighuis]

Killing the timer, for all those who haven't had a chance to vote yet.

[aaawall91]

Voted, yes

[iamgregg]

Voted for all

[Kareighuis]

I was about to enter these when a question hit me- I presume these TD types are to apply to offensive players. The thing I'm unclear about- are they to be taken away from DSTs, making them just defensive teams?

[Instinctive]

I was about to enter these when a question hit me- I presume these TD types are to apply to offensive players. The thing I'm unclear about- are they to be taken away from DSTs, making them just defensive teams?

Did our DSTs actually get points for P/K Return TDs?

They should be just Defenses. IMO.