Keeper Help

[warner892001]

Matt Cassell
Ahmad Bradshaw
Steven Jackson
Mike Tolbert
DeSean Jackson
Mike Wallace
Nate Washington
Jermaine Gresham
Packers D
Dan Carpenter
Donovan McNabb
Visanthe Shiancoe
Robert Meachem
Justin Forsett
Kevin Kolb
Arelious Benn
Dolphins D
Brandon Jackson
Jason Avant
Graham Gano
Seyi Ajirotutu
Jason Campbell
Frank Gore
Dez Bryant
Ryan Grant


Its a keeper league, 12 keepers. Which 12 players would you keep and why?

[thriftyrocker]

No brainers:

Ahmad Bradshaw
Steven Jackson
DeSean Jackson
Mike Wallace
Frank Gore
Dez Bryant

Next tier:

Jermaine Gresham
Robert Meachem
Arelious Benn
Ryan Grant

Last ones in:

Kevin Kolb
Mike Tolbert

[warner892001]

you would let the Packers D go?

[dream_017]

you would let the Packers D go?

I think the better question is - Why would you keep the Packers D? There is no need to keep a defense, there are always viable options and you can play the WW and score at least, if not better, than the top scoring defense overall.

[dream_017]

As for actual keepers - I agree with thriftyrocker for the most part. I think I might keep Cassell over Gresham The other 11 are the same.

[Indibuck]

As for actual keepers - I agree with thriftyrocker for the most part. I think I might keep Cassell over Gresham The other 11 are the same.

this.

[MadDog36]

Matt Cassell
Kevin Kolb
Ahmad Bradshaw
Steven Jackson
Frank Gore
Ryan Grant
Dez Bryant
DeSean Jackson
Mike Wallace
Arelious Benn
Robert Meachem
Visanthe Shiancoe