Wallace or Nicks? WHIR

[figurski24]

Who should I draft in my PPR keeper league, Hakeem Nicks or Mike Wallace?

[Indibuck]

I like Nicks.

[bungle613]

Phew, that is a tough one. I would give Nicks the advantage. Wallace has serious skill but if everything clicks with Nicks then he could be at least a top 5 WR for several years if not top 3.

[Venom]

I have Nicks a little higher than Wallace.

[Humdinger]

I actually like Wallace better. To me, he's a safer bet. Nicks has home run potential, but is also much more likely to get injured. I also like the consistency of Pitt over the NYG as far as fantasy production is concerned

[LS2throwed]

Wallace is very high up there, but there are only a couple of guys I'd take over Nicks. Have to take Nicks here.

[MadDog36]

Being from NC, gotta go with the Nicks beast.

[TruNinerFan]

This one is a no brainer to me, I would keep nicks

[WCcats]

Nicks is the better Red Zone Target, while Wallace relies on speed and the home run. Nicks will catch more balls in a ppr as well. I'll take Nicks.

[m16a]

Ditto to what wcats said. Wallace relies on the long ball fairly often. Nicks is a guy who will get far more receptions over the course of the season and is a better pick to hold onto in a keeper. Nicks had 79 receptions in 13 games, versus Mike Wallace's 60 receptions in 16 games. I'd keep Nicks most definitely.