Impossible Decision! Keep CJ or Foster??? WHIR

[Foolio]

This decision is absolutely killing me, I can't quit thinking about it, lol.. My league is a keeper league, each year we get to keep one player from the prior year as our "Franchise" player.. I've had CJ since his rookie year, but I got Foster last year and he won my Championship for me. I really hate to let CJ go but I'm leaning heavily towards keeping Foster just because his team situation is so much better..

Soooo, who should I keep CJ or Foster???

RB scoring is 1pt per 20yds rushing/receiving, 6pts per TD, 1pt per 50+yd TD, -2 per FMBL

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated, Thanks in advance!

[Indibuck]

flip a coin?

I would keep CJ over Foster... but you can't go too wrong either way.

[thriftyrocker]

If you only keep 1 player, I'd keep Foster. I think he scores more points in 2011, and if for some reason he fails, getting 1 elite player to keep is not hard.

[water boy]

go foster, just think 8 man in the box with Locker at qb

[JimiRayThunderaxe]

Foster. Better offense.

[Foolio]

Thanks for the thoughts guys, still a hard decision.. Ughhhhhh!!!! lol

[Those About To Rock]

Houston's offense is only going to improve.

Tennesse's offense...well, they pick up R. Moss last year? o.O lulz

Foster all the way.

[Venom]

PPR keep Foster.

Non PPR keep CJ.

Nuff said.

[LS2throwed]

I'd keep Foster in this scenario every time. It's not like he wasn't a home run hitter like CJ, he had big plays all over the place. In the passing game, running game, he's money in the red zone, he has a QB who can move the chains that the defense has to account for, an elite WR to stretch the field you can't ignore, and as a whole the Houston offense is going to be in the red zone alot more then Tennessee will with a rookie QB. Give me the guy who is going to have more chances to score. It's not like you lose no matter how you pick though, with keeping 1 player your gonna get someone back just as good, if not the same person.

[TruNinerFan]

I would keep Foster. He plays in a much better offense and teams cant really stack the box with the Houston passing offense. it is going to be tough for CJ with a rookie Qb under center