Dynasty Keepers Due! Need to cut 5! WHIR

[jmlevy]

12 team H2H, 6 playoff teams
Starting positions: QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, TE, 2 WR/RB/TE, K, DEF, 3 D, 7 BN
Keeper format: QB, WR, RB, 5 OFlex, LB, DB, 4 DFlex
Scoring: (passing) 25 yds per pt, 4 pts per TD, -1 pt per INT, (rushing) 10 yds per pt, 6 pts per TD, -2 per Fumble Lost, (receiving) .5 pt per reception, 10 yds per pt, 6 pts per TD, (return) 6 pts per TD, (defense) 1 pt per sack, 2 pts per INT, 2 pts per fumble recovery, 6 pts per TD, 2 pts per safety, 2 pts per blocked kick, (defensive player) 1 pt per solo tackle, .5 pt per assisted tackle, 1 pt per sack, 2 pts per INT, 1 pt per forced fumble, 1 pt per fumble recovery, 6 pts per defensive TD, 1 pt per pass defended

QB: Freeman, Kolb, Tebow
WR: Maclin, RWhite, SRice, SSmith (Car), Sims-Walker
RB: Charles, Forte, Addai, DBrown, TChoice
TE: Gresham, HMiller
K: Crosby
DEF: Saints
D: Dansby, EJ Henderson, Bradie James

So I need to cut five players. First thought is to cut the defensive players, since they hold the least value. I then believe that Choice and Tebow are the two most expendable.

Do you agree that these are the right players to cut? If not, who would you keep/cut?

[TexasBornCowboysFan]

I agree with cutting your 3 LBs. I would cut Miller and Brown myself.

[Venom]

The 3 IDPs are expendable given your settings. Bye bye.

I would not cut Tebow in a dynasty.

Kill your TE position. Drop them both. Focus on grabbing a young one in the draft and roll on.

Drop Dansby, Henderson, James, Gresham and Miller.

[jmlevy]

The 3 IDPs are expendable given your settings. Bye bye.

I would not cut Tebow in a dynasty.

Kill your TE position. Drop them both. Focus on grabbing a young one in the draft and roll on.

Drop Dansby, Henderson, James, Gresham and Miller.

Defensive scoring: 1 pt per solo tackle, .5 pt per assisted tackle, 1 pt per sack, 2 pts per INT, 1 pt per forced fumble, 1 pt per fumble recovery, 6 pts per defensive TD, 1 pt per pass defended

Does this change your opinion?

[Venom]

The 3 IDPs are expendable given your settings. Bye bye.

I would not cut Tebow in a dynasty.

Kill your TE position. Drop them both. Focus on grabbing a young one in the draft and roll on.

Drop Dansby, Henderson, James, Gresham and Miller.

Defensive scoring: 1 pt per solo tackle, .5 pt per assisted tackle, 1 pt per sack, 2 pts per INT, 1 pt per forced fumble, 1 pt per fumble recovery, 6 pts per defensive TD, 1 pt per pass defended

Does this change your opinion?

No.

[LS2throwed]

The only LB's you might ever want to consider keeping are Willis, Beason, Mayo types, even then you might still cut them. You don't have any so they are easy cuts. After that defense, and K or Heath Miller. You can redraft defense every single season and end up just as good on that side.

[Venom]

The only LB's you might ever want to consider keeping are Willis, Beason, Mayo types, even then you might still cut them. You don't have any so they are easy cuts. After that defense, and K or Heath Miller. You can redraft defense every single season and end up just as good on that side.

The 3 IDPs and K, D/ST are 5 easy cuts. Not sure why I thought they (K, D/ST) would be kept and TE wouldn't.

[Indibuck]

The 3 IDPs and K, D/ST are 5 easy cuts.

this.

[MadDog36]

Your TEs have SOME value at least.
If you had a top end DST I would consider keeping them and cutting Heath Miller. (personally) I think you could do better in the draft (go younger).

Cut your DST, K, and your IDPs. IDPs difference not that great anyway.

[Instinctive]

I can't believe you havent considered cutting the Kicker yet - 1st guy I would dump. Kickers can be found easily all the time.

The three IDPs are nothing special - at all. So there's three more.


I would probably cut my DST then, since they're much easier to play matchups with than any other position. But Heath is drop-able as well.