L.Blount or A. Bradshaw?

[LSUby50]

Whhich would you prefer for this season only? non-ppr.

(Blount would be an 8th round keeper, Bradshaw would be a 6th)

thanks for any input.

[LMack]

Player ranking wise I give a slight edge to Ahmad Bradshaw, but the little extra value from LeGarrette Blount is tipping it in his favor. I believe Giants' head coach Tom Coughlin when he says that he wants to give Brandon Jacobs more carries. If Jacobs vultures RZ carries and touchdowns it could sap Bradshaw's value significantly. Blount on the other hand is the cow bell in Tampa Bay. Your other keepers could affect this decision, but I doubt it.

[bungle613]

Player ranking wise I give a slight edge to Ahmad Bradshaw, but the little extra value from LeGarrette Blount is tipping it in his favor. I believe Giants' head coach Tom Coughlin when he says that he wants to give Brandon Jacobs more carries. If Jacobs vultures RZ carries and touchdowns it could sap Bradshaw's value significantly. Blount on the other hand is the cow bell in Tampa Bay. Your other keepers could affect this decision, but I doubt it.

I have the same take on Bradshaw this year. Jacobs will take 30-50 points away from Bradshaw. I have zero trust in Blount but that is me personally. Most will tell you to keep Blount and I understand there point.

I would deal one of them for someone I liked such as a Greene, Best, Forte or even DWIll as long as the deal was fair.