Keep Jamaal Charles or Ahmad Bradshaw? WHIR

[Bronco_7]

it is a 12 team keeper league where we keep 2 players each.

On the face it seems like a no brainer. However here is the problem.

Keeping Charles costs me a first round pick.
Keeping Bradshaw costs a sixth round pick.

I am picking no later than third overall so there is a chance I could get Charles at my pick if I did not keep him. Bradshaw seems like a good value at round six.

Should I roll the dice and let Charles go or keep him? The best backs to be drafted in my league I would guess would be Michael Turner, Frank Gore, LeSean McCoy, MJD. These would be the guys I would have to choose from if Charles was taken with either of the first two picks.

What would you do Keep Charles or Bradshaw?

WHIR always.

[murphysxm]

Ask yourself, would you trade Charles straight up for Bradshaw and McCoy? Keep Bradshaw and draft McCoy who may outperform Charles.........

[Bronco_7]

Ask yourself, would you trade Charles straight up for Bradshaw and McCoy? Keep Bradshaw and draft McCoy who may outperform Charles.........

Excellent point. That is a good way to look at it. Thanks. Any other opinions on this one?