Should i do Sidney RIce for Braylon Edwards?

[Lakerfan88]

Here is my team as of now
QB Brees
WR Fitzgerald
WR Mike WIllaims (TB)
WR Boldin
RB Jamal Charles
RB FOrte
TE v. davis
bn lynch
bn sidney rice
bn aj green
bn sam bradford
bn jarek cook
k crosby
def san diego

the proposed trade is for my sidney rice for braylon edwards. Its been a long time since Rice has played a whole situation, do you guys think i should do the trade or not? thanks
its a 10 team league, h2h standard scoring

[bungle613]

I think RIce is hands down the better player but his situation sucks. It isn't much better for BRaylon though so I would still give the nod to Rice. I don't expect much from either this season though. They will need to develop some serious chemistry with a QB to make a go of it this year.

[LMack]

I think the backlash from the Sidney Rice move is far too great. I agree that his value is decreased from his move to Seattle but he is still an elite level talent when healthy. Rice is going to be paired with former teammate Tavaris Jackson at QB and former OC Darrell Bevell in Seattle. The cast around him is respectable including Mike Williams, Golden Tate, Zach Miller and John Carlson. If his hip holds up, which all signs are pointing to the fact that it should, he might actually be undervalued going into 2011.

[dream_017]

I like Rice. I just don't think Braylon is going to be fantasy worthy at all.

[LSUby50]

I dont see either one being much of a fantasy factor this season , but Rice is by far the better talent so i'd stay with him. If Seattle can find a decent Qb, Rice will deliver, (but thats not likely). I dont think Braylon will deliver with or without a decent qb.