tough trade offer, looking for advice

[blountforcetrauma]

I got offered arian foster and steve smith (CAR) for jamaal charles and brandon marshall. i dont have any other good rbs on my team, so i'm kind of iffy about giving up jamaal charles. thoughts and opinions?

[LSUby50]

Charles and Foster are pretty much a toss up i think. They're definitely ranked within 2-3 spots of each other on most people's rankings. I have Marshal quite a bit higher than Smith though. If its any kind of a keeper league, it prefer Marshal by alot. It might help to see the rest of your team, but i think id pass on this. You're not trading for last year's stats, you're trading for this season and i think Charles will be every bit as good as Foster if not better.

[Venom]

I'd keep who I have.

You are downgrading at WR for a "slim to none" upgrade at RB.

[blountforcetrauma]

thanks. i was kind of leaning that way anyways, but yall helped me make my mind up.