McCoy in the 7th or McFadden in the 9th

[SlayeratCP]

I can keep one or the other. This would be my last year to keep McCoy but would still be able to keep McFadden for two more years. I like McFadden and only lose a 9th but he is fragile. McCoy is solid but not sure how Ronnie Brown will affect him.

I had a similar choice last year between Beanie Wells and McCoy and made the right choice. Hopefully you guys can help me make another good one. WHIR

[Venom]

As far as ADP goes, McCoy and McFadden are within a couple spots in the RB category.

Getting McFadden for 2 rounds later is much better value, and the fact that you can keep him next year as well makes this an easy decision for me.

[Bronco_7]

McFadden is the better value IMO. Also, as you noted Ronnie Brown reduces McCoy's value.

Please see mine

viewtopic.php?t=491955

[dblj9911]

I would have to say I would much rather have McCoy, but with the draft positions and you can keep McF for two more years I'd have to say McF. I would make sure and draft Bush as a handcuff to him. Good luck.

viewtopic.php?t=491887

[fuzzeemonkey]

I'm a big fan of McCoy and I think the value difference from losing your 7th instead of 9th isn't enough to keep McFadden over him. I like McFadden but the Raiders worry me more than the though of Brown affecting McCoys #'s. He's looks great so far this year and the team is going to be a scoring machine. McCoy is becomes even more valuable to you if it's a PPR league.