Been offered Rice and Holmes for Hillis and Roddy

[Hogan]

12 team non ppr league. We start 1 qb, 2 rbs, 3 wrs, 1 te, 1k, 1 def. Anyways been offered Ray Rice and Santonio Holmes for Peyton Hillis and Roddy White. Heres my squad...

QB--Eli Manning, Cutler
RB--Hillis, Felix Jones, Hightower, Jacobs, Reggie Bush, Ronnie Brown, Jerome Harrison
WR--Roddy White, Vincent Jackson, Jordy Nelson, Plaxico Burres
TE--Finley
K--Folk
DEF-San Diego

[bungle613]

12 team non ppr league. We start 1 qb, 2 rbs, 3 wrs, 1 te, 1k, 1 def. Anyways been offered Ray Rice and Santonio Holmes for Peyton Hillis and Roddy White. Heres my squad...

QB--Eli Manning, Cutler
RB--Hillis, Felix Jones, Hightower, Jacobs, Reggie Bush, Ronnie Brown, Jerome Harrison
WR--Roddy White, Vincent Jackson, Jordy Nelson, Plaxico Burres
TE--Finley
K--Folk
DEF-San Diego

I am higher than most (should I stop typing there???) on Ray Rice. I have him as my #1 RB in all formats. I thnk White is a star as well but downgrading to Holmes from White to get Rice is a deal I would make in a heartbeat.

[crimedoctor]

I'm not a huge believer of Holmes, ....but the upgrade to Rice is just too much. I'd pull the trigger.

[Hogan]

I actually agree with rice being the number 1 back. My major concern is tha my wr2 and wt3 are from the same team, a run oriented team at that. I think that's going to take away my only advan tage I have which is 2 potential top 12 wrs. Don't know if vjax by himself is enough to carry my wides but I feel with 2 stellar wides I can play mix and match at rb.

[Dolfan19]

I have to agree with the other posters here. I don't usually like downgrading a position in trades, but if its downgrading a WR to get my hands on Ray Rice, I would do it.

[dblj9911]

I'd take the deal and run away smilling. Rice is a huge upgrade over Hillis, you are downgrading at wr, but not by that much. I think Rice will improve his numbers across the board with Leach leading the way for him. Good luck.