Stevie Johnson for Beanie?

[jnormy]

Just got offered Steve Johnson for my Beanie Wells in a 12-team dynasty. SJ is the undisputed #1 on a team that'll probably be playing from behind and slinging it all year. But I'm feelin' Beanie this season, he's shown good burst and power so far. I need another WR playmaker and have decent RB depth. League settings and roster below.

Good deal for me? Better to counter with Hightower perhaps instead of Beanie? Help please!


12-team FB dynasty; non-PPR; start QB, RB, WR, WR, RB/WR, RB/WR, TE, K, DEF/ST
QB: D. Brees, K. Orton, C. Kaepernick (Taxi)
RB: A. Foster, F. Jackson, J. Addai, B. Wells, J. Starks, J. Snelling, T. Hightower, T. Choice, B. Tate (Taxi)
WR: D. Bowe, R. Williams, M. Williams (Sea), S. Smith (Car), S. Smith (Phi), B. Gibson, G. Little, D. Moore
TE: D. Clark, O. Daniels
K: D. Carpenter
DEF/ST: Chargers

[bungle613]

So we meet again Normy. How you doing?

It is a fair offer but I am not so sure you are not looking at dealing your future RB2 away. I would be looking at shopping Hightower (your baby, I know) Jackson and Addai and see waht you can come up with.

You can also deal a TE or add Daniels to a deal to get your WR upgrade.

[rmsanger]

I like Steve Johnson and have a historical hatred for Beanie (not a believer). I think getting another WR starter gives you a ton more flexibility in your position starters. You've also got plenty of depth at RB with Jackson, Hightower, Addai, and Starks. My inclination would be to jump all over this.

[Balcatim]

Totally agree with rmsanger. I'm high on Stevie Johnson and can't stand Beanie and you have more depth at RB than WR. I'd bite.

[crimedoctor]

It's a fair deal, .....but it seems to help you. I would pull the trigger.

[jnormy]

Thanks for the replies guys, I'm all set now! Hello again Moe, I'm doing great... and you'll be interested to know I dealt my "baby" (sniff sniff). I moved Hightower, Orton, and Roy Williams for Dez Bryant and Donald Brown. I think Dez has more dynasty value than Stevie or any of the other guys mentioned here, so I'm pretty happy with the deal... although I'll always follow Timmy's progress with love, lol.