10 team PPR - Rate Mine and I'll Rate Yours

[osbtensor]

I would give it a solid B, maybe a B+ .. I got a little carried away trying to get Stafford and should have waited a round or so but otherwise I think I picked up the best players I could grab at the time. I wanted Hightower and Bush.. but they were gone so i took Wells and Tolbert instead.

I think i'm going to drop Harrison and pickup L. Timmons or J. Tuck. Never played with an IDP and I wasn't prepared for who to pick.

1 - LeSean McCoy (rb)
2 - Roddy White (wr)
3 - Felix Jones (rb)
4 - Reggie Wayne (wr)
5 - Wes Welker (wr)
6 - Dallas Clark (te)
7 - Ben Roethlisberger (qb)
8 - Matthew Stafford (qb)
9 - Beanie Wells (rb)
10 - Mike Tolbert (rb)
11 - Nate Burleson (wr)
12 - Braylon Edwards (wr)
13 - Aaron Hernandez (te)
14 - C.J. Spiller (rb)
15 - James Harrison (d)
16 - New England (def)
17 - Josh Brown (k)

Leave a link and i'll reply to yours

[cope09]

Shady McCoy, White, Wayne, Welker, Clark...these guys are solid for a PPR league. Jones will share carries with Choice but, he'll get his share.
Roethlisberger, if he stays healthy, will have a great year.
Overall, good roster. I'd be a little concerned with RB since you have RBBC situations with Tolbert in SD and McCoy in that PHI brought in Ronnie Brown this year.
So, if you want a "grade", I give you that solid B.

viewtopic.php?t=493001

[bounce]

In a PPR, your first six guys are great. You don't have a lot of depth for a ten team league. Like was said, you have a lot of RBBC, but that's harder and harder to avoid in today's NFL.

Help me? viewtopic.php?t=493004

[jmog]

In a PPR, your first six guys are great. You don't have a lot of depth for a ten team league. Like was said, you have a lot of RBBC, but that's harder and harder to avoid in today's NFL.

Help me? viewtopic.php?t=493004

I agree with this, your starters are good but you lack solid depth which with this seasons new way of doing byes will hurt a few weeks.

[osbtensor]

probably the wrong forum but i'll throw it out there anyways... what if i could pull off a trade of stafford/tolbert for forte/freeman? The guy who got freeman really wanted stafford and offered me a trade right after the draft. i dunno if he would take this deal, but it's worth a shot? it might help out the committee issues pointed out with my RB situation.

[Bravos of Steel]

probably the wrong forum but i'll throw it out there anyways... what if i could pull off a trade of stafford/tolbert for forte/freeman? The guy who got freeman really wanted stafford and offered me a trade right after the draft. i dunno if he would take this deal, but it's worth a shot? it might help out the committee issues pointed out with my RB situation.

It's DEFINITELY worth a shot. Is this a one QB starter league? If so, Big Ben is an excellent play at QB, and I wouldn't even try and look for a QB in return. If this guy wants Stafford really bad, you might be able to do Stafford and Tolbert for JUST Forte, and you really wouldn't be losing much at all. Just my 2 cents. Awesome team by the way

help?

viewtopic.php?t=492973