PPR Maclin/Welker

[daman113]

what do you guys think in a ppr league? i was asked to trade my welker for his maclin my team is as follows

Eli Manning,
Arian Foster
Darren McFadden
Miles Austin,
Santonio Holmes,
Wes Welker,
Owen Daniels,

[WaCougMBS]

Is it a keeper/dynasty league? How many teams? How about your starting requirements?

[bungle613]

Is it a keeper/dynasty league? How many teams? How about your starting requirements?

I will say the same as WaCoug but will jump the gun a little. Redraft or keeper = Welker. Dynasty probably Maclin.

[JC.89]

Assuming this is a one year league, Welker is the obvious choice to be drafted sooner given his history, but Maclin could easily outproduce him for the second season in a row.

[dpaine1988]

I like Welker here, I think he is in for a big year and there is some concern over Maclin still, never know.

help? viewtopic.php?t=493149

[daman113]

Its a one year league... 12 man team... 1 qb 2 rbs 2wrs 1te 1wr/te flex kicker defense... I like welker here as well due to past stats, but maclin looks promising, just worried about his illness..

[dblj9911]

I'd keep Welker in a redraft, hands down. He is a ppr beast and is now well over a year removed from a knee injury that was supposed to keep him out for the first half of last year. Unless he adds a ton more to this deal keep Welker and watch him rack up catch after catch for you. Good luck.

viewtopic.php?t=493387

[sixer03fan]

PPR = welker

[daman113]

thanks for the push guys... i was really on the fence about it but not anymore... i will not do the trade and keep welker